Your Local Expert
Contact Patrick Today
Ready to buy or sell in Central Florida? With 18+ years of experience and 400+ homes sold, I am here to guide you every step of the way. Let's talk about your real estate goals.
ABOUT THE RESERVE AT LAKE MARY
The Reserve at Lake Mary, Florida is one of Lake Mary‘s most popular and consistently sought-after established family neighborhoods, offering residents an outstanding combination of spacious single-family homes, mature landscaping, a welcoming community atmosphere, and one of the most convenient and well-positioned locations in all of Seminole County. Built between 2001 and 2004, The Reserve at Lake Mary features a beautifully maintained collection of homes on generous lots in a peaceful residential setting just minutes from some of Lake Mary‘s most valued community amenities and destinations. If you are searching for homes for sale in Lake Mary FL, The Reserve at Lake Mary offers an outstanding combination of space, value, and location that is consistently difficult to match anywhere else in the market.
The Reserve at Lake Mary is a well-established neighborhood featuring homes ranging from approximately 2,405 to 3,720 square feet with 4 to 6 bedrooms and 3 to 4 bathrooms on lots ranging from approximately 0.18 to 0.40 acres. The neighborhood’s mature tree canopy, well-maintained homes, and strong sense of community pride create a consistently attractive and cohesive neighborhood aesthetic that has contributed enormously to The Reserve at Lake Mary’s enduring appeal and reliable property values over more than two decades. With 14 homes sold over the past three years at a median sale price of $685,250 and a median sale-to-list ratio of 97.8% — with several homes selling at or above asking price — The Reserve at Lake Mary reflects the kind of consistent buyer demand that defines Lake Mary‘s most sought-after residential neighborhoods.
DISCOVER MORE ABOUT THE RESERVE AT LAKE MARY
The Reserve at Lake Mary was developed in the early 2000s as one of Lake Mary‘s most thoughtfully planned family neighborhoods, delivering a collection of spacious single-family homes on generous lots in one of the most convenient and well-connected locations in all of Seminole County. Over the past two decades The Reserve at Lake Mary has established itself as one of the most recognized and consistently in-demand addresses in all of Lake Mary attracting families and professionals who value spacious homes, mature neighborhood character, top-rated schools, and outstanding access to everything Lake Mary has to offer.
Based on sales data from the past three years, 14 homes have sold in The Reserve at Lake Mary ranging from 2,405 to 3,720 square feet with 4 to 6 bedrooms and 3 to 4 bathrooms on lots ranging from approximately 0.18 to 0.40 acres. Sale prices have ranged from $540,000 to $780,000 with a median sale price of $685,250 and an average price per square foot of $230. Homes in The Reserve at Lake Mary have sold at a median of 97.8% of list price — with several homes selling at or above asking price — reflecting strong and consistent buyer demand and well-supported property values throughout the neighborhood.
Beyond the neighborhood, The Reserve at Lake Mary’s location puts residents within easy reach of some of Lake Mary‘s most valued destinations. Mayfair Country Club and Golf Course is just minutes away offering outstanding golf and club amenities for residents who enjoy an active lifestyle. Lake Mary Preparatory School is conveniently nearby making The Reserve at Lake Mary a particularly attractive option for families seeking private school access. And the Lake Mary Sports Complex at 550 Rantoul Lane — home of the 2024 Little League World Series Champions and one of Seminole County‘s finest public recreational facilities — is just around the corner offering tennis, baseball, basketball, a skate park, splash park, and more for residents of all ages.
THE RESERVE AT LAKE MARY HIGHLIGHTS & AMENITIES
The Reserve at Lake Mary offers residents an outstanding collection of lifestyle advantages, neighborhood character, and location benefits that have made it one of Lake Mary‘s most consistently popular and sought-after established family neighborhoods for over two decades. From spacious well-built homes and mature tree-lined streets to a community park and outstanding proximity to Lake Mary‘s best destinations, everything about The Reserve at Lake Mary reflects its status as one of the finest established family neighborhoods in all of Seminole County.
Community Park & Playground
The Reserve at Lake Mary features a beautifully maintained community park and playground nestled beneath a stunning canopy of mature live oak trees — one of the most inviting and well-used amenities in the neighborhood. The park provides families with a shaded and welcoming outdoor gathering space perfect for afternoon play, casual neighborhood socializing, and everything in between. The playground is a beloved feature of daily life in The Reserve at Lake Mary and a major draw for families with young children who are looking for a true neighborhood community feel.
Spacious Well-Built Homes
Homes in The Reserve at Lake Mary were built between 2001 and 2004 and range from approximately 2,405 to 3,720 square feet with 4 to 6 bedrooms, 3 to 4 bathrooms, and 2 to 3 car garages on lots ranging from approximately 0.18 to 0.40 acres. The quality of construction and the generous floor plans available throughout The Reserve at Lake Mary make it one of the most practical and comfortable established neighborhoods in all of Lake Mary for growing families and move-up buyers seeking space and value in a mature neighborhood setting.
Mayfair Country Club & Golf Course
One of The Reserve at Lake Mary’s most distinctive location advantages is its proximity to Mayfair Country Club and Golf Course — one of the most established and well-regarded golf and country club destinations in the Lake Mary area. For residents who enjoy golf, dining, and an active club lifestyle, having Mayfair just minutes from home is one of the most valued and sought-after aspects of living in The Reserve at Lake Mary.
Lake Mary Preparatory School
The Reserve at Lake Mary is conveniently located near Lake Mary Preparatory School — one of the most respected private schools in all of Seminole County. For families seeking a private school option with outstanding academics and a strong educational program, the proximity of Lake Mary Prep to The Reserve at Lake Mary is a meaningful and highly valued location advantage that sets this neighborhood apart from many other established communities in the Lake Mary area.
Lake Mary Sports Complex
The Reserve at Lake Mary is just minutes from the Lake Mary Sports Complex at 550 Rantoul Lane — one of Seminole County‘s finest and most comprehensive public recreational facilities. Home of the 2024 Little League World Series Champions, the complex offers residents of all ages access to tennis courts, baseball fields, basketball courts, a skate park, batting tunnels, a splash park, a playground, and scenic walking paths all within one beautifully maintained campus.
Top-Rated Schools
The Reserve at Lake Mary is served by Seminole County Public Schools — consistently ranked as one of the top school districts in all of Florida. Students attend highly regarded Lake Mary area schools known for outstanding academics, championship athletics, and exceptional extracurricular programs.
Prime Lake Mary Location
The Reserve at Lake Mary’s location in Lake Mary provides residents with outstanding connectivity throughout the greater Orlando metropolitan area. The I-4 corridor and Lake Mary‘s corporate employment hub are just minutes away, Colonial TownPark’s dining and retail district is nearby, downtown Orlando is approximately 25 to 30 minutes south, and Orlando International Airport is roughly 30 to 35 minutes away making The Reserve at Lake Mary one of the most conveniently located established family neighborhoods in all of Seminole County.
The Reserve at Lake Mary FL FAQs
Browse Other Communities
